Nuclear Power in Poland
(updated April 2013)
- Poland plans to have nuclear power from about 2025 as part of a diverse energy portfolio, moving it away from heavy dependence on coal and imported gas.
- The nuclear plant will be a joint venture of three utilities and a copper miner, all state-owned.
- It earlier planned to have a stake in the new Visaginas nuclear power plant in Lithuania.
In 2011, Poland produced some 163 billion kWh gross
from 33 GWe of mostly coal plant. Coal provided 141 TWh (86.5%) of the
electricity, gas 5.8 TWh (3.5%), biofuels 7.9 TWh (4.8%) and wind 2.7 TWh
(1.6%). Net exports were 1.4 billion kWh and in 2010 domestic consumption was
118 billion kWh, or 3100 kWh/yr per capita.
Poland has the largest reserves of coal in the EU (14 billion tonnes); and in 2008, 92% of electricity came from coal, as well as 89% (279,000 TJ) of the nation's heat usage (313,000 TJ). About two thirds of the country's gas supply (total 14 billion m3) comes from Russia with the price pegged to oil, but this dependence is set to change with the advent of shale gas domestically, though prospects of this are lower than originally anticipated. The prospect of increased dependence on Russia rules out any consideration of new gas-fired generation capacity.
Poland has traditionally been a net electricity exporter, mostly to Czech Republic and Slovakia, but recent years has seen a reduction in export levels as domestic demand continues to grow, and the country is likely to become a net importer unless capacity additions are made.
Poland's own electricity consumption is forecast to grow by 54% to 2030, but under the EU's strict climate policy targets the country will need to diversify away from coal.
In February 2012 the state-owned Polska Grupa Energetyczna SA (PGE) adopted a plan to invest over 330 billion zloty ($103 billion) between 2012 and 2035. This would raise its generating capacity from 13.1 GWe, to 21.3 GWe by 2035. Currently, PGE generates two-thirds of its power from lignite, with most of the rest coming from hard coal. By 2035, the company aims to generate about 36% of its electricity using 6 GWe of nuclear capacity, with 11% coming from gas, 14% from renewables, 33% from lignite and 5% from coal. PGE supplies 42% of Poland's electricity now, and expects to increase this to 46% by 2035.
The immediate priorities are shale gas exploration and the nuclear program,
expected to cost Zloty 56 billion and 80 billion respectively by about 2025.
However, the extent of shale gas resources is unknown, and ExxonMobil has pulled
out of exploration in Poland.
Plans for nuclear capacity
The Polish cabinet decided early in 2005 that for energy diversification and to reduce CO2 and sulfur emissions the country should move immediately to introduce nuclear power, so that an initial plant might be operating soon after 2020. A 2009 report to the Ministry of the Economy identified nuclear as the most cost effective method of CO2 abatement of the major generating options. A resolution by the council of ministers then called for the construction of at least two plants in Poland, or at least 4.6 GWe out of a predicted 52 GWe total capacity - to provide 15% of power, with coal's share falling to 60% by 2030. This plan remains in place. Three locations were short-listed as likely sites for a plant: Zarnowiec, Kopan and Lubiatowo/ Klempicz. Sites in Nowe Miasto and Pilica (Mazovia province) and Belchatow were also being considered. Under the current schedule site selection will not be finalized before the end of 2013.
The five-stage government plan in 2009 envisaged legislation for a regulatory framework in 2010 (passed in May 2011), investor, site, technology and construction arrangements over 2011-13, technical plans and site works 2014-15, construction of the first unit 2016-20 and successive units constructed by 2030.
In order to deliver the government's objectives, PGE, as Poland's largest power group by generating capacity, announced in January 2009 plans to build two nuclear power plants, each with a capacity of 3,000 MWe, one in the north, probably at Zarnoweic, and one in the east of the country. The Ministry of Economy set out a new nuclear power program in November 2010, and this was approved by government in January 2011, and confirmed by the PGE Board in February 2012. PGE estimates that the cost would be EUR 2500-3000/kW for a modern plant, hence total project cost of up to EUR 10.5 billion. It estimates the levelized cost of generating electricity from nuclear power plants is between €6.5 and €6.8 cents per kWh, which "justifies construction of plants under most scenarios."
PGE aims to hold 51% of the projects through PGE EJ as part of a consortium with foreign strategic partners which can bring finance from their export credit agencies (ECAs).
PGE will draw up agreements with potential strategic investors once the technology is chosen, since some contenders are closely linked to reactor vendors. PGE plans to finance 15% of the project from its own equity, with strategic partners taking another 15%, while 50% would be sought from ECAs and ‘perhaps 20%’ being commercial debt. In July 2012 it was reported that state-owned copper miner KGHM Polska Miedz SA and power utilities Tauron Polska Energia SA and ENEA would take minority stakes in the $10.3 to $11.3 billion project with PGE. A letter of intent was signed in September and an agreement was envisaged by the end of March 2013, but it appears that the proposal has lapsed. The need for state financial support for the project is widely acknowledged, but the treasury maintains that it is unaffordable.
The government approved legislation amending the country's Nuclear Energy Law to “provide for the establishment of a transparent and stable regulatory framework covering the entire investment process” by the National Atomic Energy Agency (PAA), which will oversee construction of the plants. This was passed decisively by parliament in May 2011, by 407 votes to 2. It covers plant operation and the management of radioactive waste and used fuel. Further legislation was passed at the end of June. PGE expected to sign a commercial contract by the end of 2013 for the first 3000 MWe plant, so that first concrete is poured in 2016.
A tender for an engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) contractor was expected by mid 2012, but as it became apparent that the EPC contract could not be separated from the choice of a strategic partner and a financing model, PGE decided to set aside the traditional separate EPC contract package approach for the time being, and look at wider options, including a more integrated contracting model and a broader scope for the contract.
Site qualification and selection will proceed until 2014, with Zarnowiec, Choczewo and Gaski all being under consideration, the first two in Pomerania, Gaski in West Pomerania, but evidently less prospective. Zarnowiec is on a lake, the other two on the Baltic coast. Following a public tender process, in January 2013 PGE EJ1
awarded an $81.5 million contract to WorleyParsons to carry out site
characterisation, licensing and permitting for the project.
The entity PGE EJ1 is set up to build the first plant and it will be future operator and licensee. PGE aims to have one main contractor, responsible for nuclear island, conventional island, civil engineering, balance of plant and site civil works, in line with IAEA guidelines. The first unit is now expected to be operational in 2024, the second in 2029.
In November 2009 France and Poland signed a joint declaration on energy, environment and climate that calls for France to assist Poland in the construction of nuclear power plants. PGE then signed an agreement to work with EdF to investigate using EPR technology for Poland, and Areva has said that it would bid in conjunction with EdF. A similar non-exclusive agreement was signed with GE Hitachi early in 2010, regarding ABWR and ESBWR technology. Westinghouse has signed a similar agreement for its AP1000. South Korea's Kepco also intends to bid for Polish units. Russian technology does not appear to be under consideration.
Poland had four 440 MWe Russian VVER-440 units under construction in the 1980s at Zarnowiec, but these were cancelled in 1990 and the components were sold. The site remained a leading contender for at least 1500 MWe of capacity.
In July 2006 Lithuania invited Poland to join with Estonia and Latvia in building a new large reactor in Lithuania, to replace the Ignalina units being shut down at EU insistence. Polish participation would justify a larger and more economical unit such as an EPR. In February 2007 the three Baltic states and Poland agreed to build a new nuclear plant there, initially of 3200 MWe. Lithuania as host would have 34% of the project and Poland, Latvia and Estonia 22% each. At least one unit of the project was expected to be operating by 2015. Total cost would be some EUR 6 billion. E.On earlier expressed interest in investing in such a unit. Poland said that unless it has access to at least 1000 MWe of the project, later increased to 1200 MWe, it would not be worth building the transmission lines to Poland.
In July 2008 the Lithuanian government with energy companies from Latvia, Estonia and Poland (Latvenergo, Eesti Energia and Polska Grupa Energetyczna) established the Visaginas project development company Visagino Atomine Elektine (VAE) for the new 3200-3400 MWe nuclear power plant. Lithuania holds 51% of this, and the others 16% each, but the JV will be reconstituted later as a project implementation company with different share split related to long-term equity. Though located close to the Soviet-era Ignalina plant, the new one will be called Visaginas after the nearby town of that name. Lithuania wants at least 34% of the new plant (1090-1160 MWe), Poland wanted 1000 MWe, while Latvia and Estonia want 400-600 MWe each. However, only one reactor may now be envisaged, at a cost of EUR 3-5 billion, and completion date is 2020. In December 2011 PGE withdrew from the project, saying that VAE's conditions were unacceptable to PGE, and it wanted to focus on its own plans anyway. PGE also said it would not buy any power from Russia's Baltic plant in Kaliningrad. (Further details in Lithuania paper)
Meanwhile, and apart from possible Polish participation in the Baltic states nuclear plant, a high-voltage (400 kV) 1000 MW DC PowerBridge or LitPol Link costing EUR 250-300 million to improve transmission capacity between Lithuania and Poland is to be built, the first 500 MW stage by 2015. It will be half funded by the EC. This follows inauguration of an interconnector between Estonia and Finland - Estlink, a 150 kV, 350 MW DC cable costing EUR 110 million and also supported by EC funding.
A further major transmission link, of 700 to 1000 MWe is proposed undersea between Sweden and Lithuania, to allow power from the new joint reactor to be exported to Scandinavia.
Poland joined the Global Nuclear Energy Partnership (GNEP) in September 2007 and the OECD Nuclear Energy Agency (NEA) in November 2010.
Regulation and safety
The Nuclear Energy Law was amended in 2011 to “provide for the establishment of a transparent and stable regulatory framework covering the entire investment process” by the National Atomic Energy Agency (PAA). PAA has signed cooperation agreements with the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), the French Autorite de Surete Nucleaire (ASN), and expects also to do so with the new South Korean Nuclear Safety and Security Commission (NSSC). In March 2010 a nuclear cooperation agreement related to nuclear safety and a legal and regulatory framework for a nuclear industry was signed with Japan. In July 2010 a nuclear cooperation agreement was signed with the USA.
Research & Development
The National Centre for Nuclear Research (NCBJ) has a 30 MWt multi-purpose research reactor – Maria - in operation. This started up in 1974 at Swierk, south of Warsaw. It was modified in the 1980s and resumed regular operation in 1993 as part of a European network of reactors for production of molybdenum-99. In 2012 the Centre proposed making this, at least in its materials test role, a satellite of the CEA’s 100 MWt Jules Horowitz Reactor (JHR) in France. JHR is under construction by the CEA at Cadarache in southern France and is expected to be in regular operation in 2014. It is being built and will be operated in the framework of a “consortium agreement” among several organizations, including Spain’s Ciemat, Belgium’s SCK, Czech Republic’s NRI, Finland’s VTT, Israel’s IAEC, India’s DAE, and Japan’s JAEA. NCBJ aspires to join this team.
The Centre is also keen to promote construction of a high-temperature gas-cooled reactor (HTR) for industrial applications such as coal gasification and fertilizer production.
A public opinion poll in December 2006 carried out for the National Atomic Energy Agency showed that 60% supported construction of nuclear power plants to reduce the country's dependence on natural gas and to reduce CO2 emissions. In contrast to NIMBY attitudes elsewhere, 48% said they would favour such a plant being built in their neighbourhood because of its immediate local benefits including lower power cost. A September 2009 poll showed that 70% of Poles would support having a nuclear power plant within 100 km of their homes.
The application of safeguards in Poland under the NPT safeguards agreement INFCIRC/179, in force since October 1972, was suspended on 1 March 2007, on which date the Euratom agreement of April 1973 entered into force for Poland.